home living it resourcing networking gathering training

LIVING IT - MEAT + DRINK - CHURCH + CULTURE - CHURCH OF ENGLAND NEWSPAPER ARTICLES

 

'It's church, Jim, but not as we know it'
In the final part of our series on reaching the emerging generation, Mal Calladine looks at the issues for those trying to be Church in the 18-35 generation…

Last month we left the Roxy. The nightclub we've been meeting in for the last two years, where God has met powerfully with many 100's of young adults, closed in preparation to be knocked down. We've lost our strategic city centre venue, which has allowed our church to have up to 1500 people through the doors on a Sunday (with over 70% under 40). As we worshipped there for the last time, many of the 400 young adults present graffiti-ed every available wall with what God has done in their lives in that building. The openness & emotion in what was daubed by fingers dipped in paint was amazing " Thank you for ·Meeting me ·Speaking 2 me ·Healing me ·Filling me ·Changing me ·Loving me ·Giving me life….". So what will happen to these people committed to church in a new generation? How will they 'be church' without a place to meet for a big weekly celebration? What do they want church to be about anyway?

What is the challenge?

There are few models of vibrant faith community to the emerging generation. 88% of teenagers in church in USA now leave at the end of secondary school & don't come back. The message seems to be that until they get a mortgage, a wife, 2.4 children, a decent job, and buy-in to middle-aged, middle-class christianity then there is no place for them to live out their christian life meaningfully. Our understanding of a church response to this generation can be limited to 'alternative worship' services or 'twenties groups' which have gained a reputation for either being a place for the socially "challenged" or a place to pair off the younger singles in the church!

Over the last 30 years under 35's have haemorrhaged from the church. We cannot cosset ourselves in the belief that the small minority of young adults who are comfortable in the retreating paradigm of church defined by their parents will arrest this decline. Before most of our deaths there will be no church left at all in this country if current statistical trends continue.

Our world is ever increasingly post-modern, post-christendom and fragmented, with people in 'tribal' networks of like-minded worldviews & emphases rather than in neighbourhood communities. Irvine Welsh the novelist & playwright who captured the amoral yet 'feeling' dissatisfaction of a generation in the 1995 movie 'Trainspotting' summed up the ship in which we sail & the lack of places of anchorage when he noted: "consumer capitalism has eaten up the church, the state, the trade unions, extended families, everywhere that people learn morality."

So in response, is God raising up a church that is evocative & representative of the culture to which it relates?

What is church in a new generation?

It's less about age, than worldview - people who have the same cultural reference points, interests or style. Every emerging expression of church I see God has given 'wise old heads', people wanting to relate in that generation's context & willing to fit with their emphases & agenda. For some, a focus on emerging church will not be their bag. That's fine as long as detractors remember that whatever they do also has a culture, style & emphasis that engages some but not all, especially those in the emerging cultural paradigms.

My experience is that the word 'church' is a real stumbling block for church leaders. We all have our conditioning of what this word means: this amorphous, hard-to-pin-down concept that we are supposed to lead! In a deanery chapter there is the potential for as many different definitions of what is the essence of church as there are people in the room. The reason I believe it is so hard to pin down is that church is essentially relational. There are 96 images of church in the New Testament in four main spheres but all of them are relational. This has to be the starting point for our questions about church. How do we express our relationships? With God? With the people who share our faith journey? With our world? So what are some of the new things God is doing in these 3 areas?

1) relationship with God: New Ways of Worship

I would identify four arenas of worship that groups are using that reflect cultural meeting points:-

1. The concert: the primary form of worship style for the last 30 years. A band or orchestra led concert, with a stage & a focus to the front.
2. The museum: where the worship leader becomes a 'curator'. Prayer stations, celtic pathways like the 'labyrinth' used at St Pauls Cathedral & other installations that allow people to interact with God in their own time & space. The arena where liturgy is used most effectively.
3. The night club: DJ led either in your face or more ambient - taize with attitude! Repetitive dance music, loud, anonymous & spiritual, that allows people to individually commune with God.

4. The café bar/pub: Worship in community - small groups of friends who relate to each other as they relate to God in informal ways in small informal settings.

2) relationship with other believers: New Forms of Community

The 40 odd small groups that made up our celebration at the Roxy have been able to re-structure themselves in new ways to reflect what they are trying to do. We perceive four different forms of church expressed in our lives (which we see reflected in scripture) that all have a different purpose. The four 'vehicles' we use are accountability, small group, congregation & celebration. Each different size has a different dynamic & role, with different emphases & purpose.

How we do church



Accountability - I believe is the most important for us, because it's what stops people from having a 'rollercoaster' faith where high points of closeness to God are superceded by events around them or failure to live a life of holiness. This is the place of greatest trust & openness where closest friends hold one another to account for the life choices they are making. Small group - we think of as an 'extended household', a family unit who share lives, walk into each others homes without knocking, eat together lots and support each other. A meaningful community or 'belonging place' that is vibrant, fun, and attractive to others. I believe the heart cry of this generation is to belong - and God's promise (in Psalm 68) is that He sets the lonely in families.

Most of the young adult forms of church I have seen have started as small groups (often sub-divided into accountability 2's & 3's), and as they have grown and multiplied have seen a congregation develop which is big enough to make an impact on their community (run programmes, have a football team etc) yet is small enough for people to feel like they belong. We have found this size is the key mission vehicle to a generation - 'small enough to care, big enough to dare'! This means about 30 - 70 people, anymore and you lose the community dynamic and have the demands of the biggest size. We call this the celebration level in which we join with the wider church for the bits that are high quality & high organisation, in our context band led worship, teaching & prayer ministry.

Some of our people only engage in one or two of these, but most attend more as there is something different to be received from all four. Jesus operated on these four levels with his close confidants, his group ('the 12'), the wider group ('the 72') and the crowds. The problems come when we think we're supposed to do the same thing in different sizes - the worst small group is one that tries to replicate big church with a 40 minute 'sermon' & 'big band worship' by those who can't sing or play instruments! The smaller the size the higher the level of intimacy in how we relate, the bigger the group the less inclusively participative it is, but the higher the quality of word & worship. Big choirs & organs are for cathedrals - not the aspiration of small group worship! It's all about horses for courses…

3) relationship with our world: New focus on Mission

Mission, whether presence, persuasion or proclamation is different in a world of no absolute truths, where "it's great if it works for you, but that doesn't mean it has to work for me'. Someone in the emerging generation would seem to have one of 3 different responses to how they want to be involved in mission:-

i) mono cultural - looking to reach 'people like us' with an emphasis on common reference points (eg TV programmes), shared story, culture, or interests. These reference points rarely have anything to do with church and lead to expressions of church & engagement with culture that are quite different from what has gone before! Tend to be experimental, and able to adapt & change - not necessarily there for the long haul.

ii) multi generational - a commitment to 'family' church, normally defined culturally by the retreating paradigm. In my experience the majority of those in the emerging generation who are more comfortable with this are those who have grown up in the church & are used to a culture that is formed by the generation older than them. For those who didn't grow up in church this is neither a culture to which they aspire or relate. Tend to be a more stable environment, but slow to respond to change.

iii) cross cultural - those whose heart is broken for the poor. Unconcerned about 'cultural relevance' like the first group, we are seeing many young adults choosing to move into the inner city. The most famous example is the Eden Project in Manchester but there are many less feted examples of young adults moving into poor, urban communities. Tend to be 'underground' and sacrificial in sharing their lives with those they are amongst.

An emerging generation checklist

A generation looking for…

· Community (a place of belonging & ownership)
· Accountability (a place of complete openness, 'monsters disappear when you turn on the light')
· 'Wholistic' Spirituality (seeing God in the whole of life, sacred & secular)
· The chance to make a difference (being involved in seeing God's transforming power in the world)
· a Challenge (a small challenge leads to small commitment, a big challenge leads to big commitment).
· Experience (that validates the spoken concepts - interpreting theology through experience)
· 'Fruit' (that's fine, but does it work? A pragmatic approach that leads people to go more where they see God is working .than with denominational allegiance)
· Time (to make a difference - more concerned about being 'time rich' & 'money poor', than 'money rich' & 'time poor')

A releasing leader's checklist

Do you…?

· Release those of the generation below you to pursue their dreams (just use them to serve your agenda or oversee new things you may not fully understand?)
· Confront (Leaders are less respected who 'let things lie' - if you don't confront then you condone. A generational backlash to the British tendency to sweep under the carpet?)
· Look to live out spiritual father & mother relationships (there are many guardians, but not many fathers cf I Corin 4)
· Use story more than concepts as your platform communication style (look to the news media - it's all story & stats, hardly a concept in sight!)
· Look for a response to God's word (not a notional, academic, cerebral commitment, but a response of experiencing Him & his power to go & live it out)
· Make big calls to commitment (in the context of ownership for those committing)
· Want to model a lifestyle especially in key relationships - your household & your 'team'. This can only be done by having 'an open home' to some extent. (your walk talks & your talk talks but your walk talks louder than your talk talks!)
· Speak from experience - with authenticity & integrity (you can pontificate on a life issue but have you actually done it?)
· Lead by example, especially in being vulnerable (honesty in lifestyle, openness and humility that sets a tone)
· Teach on 'living the life' (focussing more on life as a disciple or pilgrim, than making a conversion decision)

So...

Jesus' issue was not about new wine but new wineskins (Luke 5 vv37-39). There is always 'new wine' being produced - the new thing God is doing in our changing world. The issue Jesus highlights is that this wine "must" be in new containers - are we open to the flexible, new structures to hold it? Whilst Jesus then stresses that those who've tasted the more mature wine will say it's better. We have to face that even our own 'new wine' is becoming more mature & those who have experienced that vintage will "say it's better". Are we guilty of just focussing on enjoying the better tasting old stuff? If nothing is done structurally to hold the new wine God is making in our midst and we try to keep it in our present understanding of church, then Jesus' words seem to intimate the 'now stuff of God' will burst the old skins. I believe this is both the warning and the opportunity of the times in which we live.

Mal Calladine is the leader of 'Realm', a celebration made up six young adult congregations which are all a part of St Thomas', Sheffield.

Recommended Reading:
'church next' - Revd Dr Eddie Gibbs - buy it in the market place!

Mal Calladine
Article by The Church of England Newspaper

 
Got a view or a question on this stuff - get chatting
 
upinoutliving it - meat + drink
relevant resources
>Church of England Newspaper
>part 1 - Graham Cray
>part 2 - Mark Bailey
>part 3 - Simon Kirby
meat + drink home
meat - living the life
drink - church + culture
>get in touch with us
© Tribal Generation